I was talking about WEP keys, not WPA, I though my quote from your post would've been self-explanatory, oh well...
Let me re-phrase my question;
If we force a station to try and authenticate with us via Karma or something,
we send him a challenge, the station encrypt it with the WEP keys,
we then try to decrypt the ciphertext with a dictionnary file until the result equals the plaintext challenge which we already know since we created it.
I was asking if this concept was somewhat practicable, or is there some hidden trickery that would prevent this attack.
It is less convenient than AP-targeted WEP cracking, but it would be a very effective and decentralized way to mass harvest a lot potential weak WEP keys for multiple AP, 4-ways handshake style, but better.