I was able to get it running following the standard procedure as you have outlined. BUT, I was unable to (and still am unable to) do it from my home network. I had to take it to work and perform the steps on a network utilizing a completely different ISP.
As mentioned above, i'm seeing something strange that I think is impacting my ability to work with this at home. Without the pineapple connected and with no other device using the 172.16.42.1 address, I was still able to receive a ping reply from it. So I performed a tracert (see screen shot provided in previous post) and found that several hops into my ISP, there's a device with the 172.16.42.1 replying. I thought this IP range was dedicated to Private IP spaces? If so, how would i get a reply like this?
I haven't had a chance to research if it's possible to assign a different static IP to the pineapple. But if it's possible, i will try to see if this grants me access to the pineapple while connected to my home network.
Open to suggestions or input on this :-)